Showing posts with label Dean Knuth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dean Knuth. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2015

The Golf Digest Handicap: Why Bother?

Golf Digest started offering a handicap service in 2013.  The question is “Why bother to offer or get a Golf Digest handicap?”  Golf Digest was once the flagship magazine of the golf community.  It has been listing badly as of late.  It is hard to be current when you only publish once a month.  Its time lapsed photography used for instruction seems antiquated in today’s internet and iphone world.  In an effort to be relevant, the editor’s decided Golf Digest should become hip – the magazine for millennials.  The magazine recently featured articles about the best looking girlfriends on Tour, the joy of playing shirtless, the thrill of having sex on the golf course, and a cover story on Paulina Gretsky—golf’s equivalent of a  Kardashian.  It appears Golf Digest has traded its dignity for stagnant circulation at best.

The Golf Digest handicap may be a gesture of atonement for its sophomoric behavior.   If public service was the motive, however, the Golf Digest handicap would have to have some value for there to be absolution. Unfortunately, the Golf Digest handicap is of little benefit to the player for the following reasons:

Not Universal – For a handicap system to be effective, competing players must use the same handicap system.  Golf Digest argues its handicap “allows golfers of all skill levels to compete against one another fairly.”  This assumes other players have a Golf Digest handicap which is very unlikely. If the other players have USGA handicaps, they would probably look upon your Golf Digest handicap like a cashier looks upon a $3 bill.[1] 
No Peer Review – An absolute necessity for a handicap system is peer review.  Peer review gives some assurance (maybe p=.85) a handicap is a true measure of a player’s potential. Peer review is absent from the Golf Digest handicap system. 
Oversold – Golf Digest argues its handicap is “a way to determine where your game needs the most help.”  Handicap systems, however, can identify a bad golfer but not pinpoint why he is bad.  At best, the Golf Digest handicap can put you in a class of players (e.g. 20+ handicap) who usually have these deficiencies (e.g., sliced drives, inadequate short game).  Since players are typically aware of their weaknesses, it is unlikely the Golf Digest handicap will provide any new information.
Absence of Slope Rating – The Golf Digest Handicap was developed by Dean Knuth, former Director of Handicapping at the USGA, who was responsible for the adoption of the Slope System.  Knuth argues the Golf Digest handicap is fair and “portable.”  His statement goes against 30 years of arguments made by himself and the USGA proclaiming only the Slope System can make handicaps portable.   If you are a muni player (Slope Rating = 110) and Jerry Tarde, Managing Editor of Golf Digest, asks you to be his guest at Pine Valley (Slope Rating = 155), you will be at a serious disadvantage with your Golf Digest handicap. 
Measure of Progress – The Golf Digest handicap does let a player measure how his performance changes over time.  A player with a minimal knowledge of spreadsheets, however, can track a USGA handicap using actual Course and Slope Ratings.  If that is too difficult, the player can track his differential (Adjusted Score – USGA Course Rating) and get essentially the same information provided by the Golf Digest handicap. 

A better explanation than public service for the free handicap is Golf Digest’s desire to increase visits to its website.  Golf Digest has been giving away “free stuff” for years in hopes of stemming subscriber defections.  For example, it has tie-in sales where the magazine is given away if another product is purchased—e.g., a golf association membership or a large purchase at a golf store.  (Note: About 25 percent of Golf digest’s circulation is listed as “free or nominal rate distribution.”)  Now it is giving away a free handicap in hopes of harvesting the player’s e-mail address or having him click on an ad that appears on the posting sheet.
 
The Golf Digest handicap is aimed at the universe of players who 1) Are not serious enough about the game to get a USGA handicap,  2) Are serious enough to want to improve their game, and 3) Are aware of the existence of the Golf Digest handicap.  This should be a very small population indeed.   Golf Digest’s gambit should fail as both a marketing ploy and as a viable handicap.  To answer the title question of this post, neither the magazine nor the player should bother with the Golf Digest handicap.
 
Appendix
The USGA vs. Golf Digest Handicap

For legal reasons, Golf Digest could not use the USGA handicap formula.   The Golf Digest handicap differs from the USGA handicap in the following four ways:

1. The Course Rating is estimated solely as a function of yardage.
2. There is no Slope Rating.
3. Different equitable stroke control procedures.
4. The sample size of scores is smaller.

Each of these differences affects the difference between a USGA and Golf Digest handicap:

Course Rating formulae – The USGA’s course rating formula for men is:

                Course Rating(USGA) = Yardage/220 +40.9 + SOV
                                                 SOV= Scratch Obstacle Value
The Golf Digest formula for the Course Rating is:
                Course Rating(GD) = Yardage/200 +39

For all courses greater than 4200 yards, the Course Rating(GD) will be larger than the yardage component of the  Course Rating(USGA).  This difference could be a proxy for SOV which the Course Rating(GD) does not explicitly incorporate.  Instead, it could be assuming the SOV is an increasing function of yardage.
This adjustment for omitting the SOV may not be sufficient.  The table below shows the USGA and Golf Digest Course Ratings for a selection of courses in Southern California.  The USGA Course Rating is higher is 6 of the 7 cases.  Therefore, the Golf Digest Course Rating formula would, on average, yield a slightly higher handicap than the USGA Course Rating formula.    

Table
USGA and Golf Digest Course Ratings

Course(Tee)
Yardage
USGA Rating
Golf Digest Rating
Difference
Los Angeles CC(White)
6486
72.4
71.4
+1.0
Riviera(White)
6531
72.2
71.7
+0.5
Torrey Pines South(White)
6628
73.1
72.1
+1.0
PGA West Stadium(White)
6166
70.2
69.8
+0.4
Rancho La Quinta Jones(White)
5986
68.6
68.9
-0.3
Wilshire CC(Blue)
6265
70.7
70.3
+.04
Bel Air CC(White)
6235
71.0
70.2
+0.8

Absence of the Slope Rating – The Golf Digest Handicap system is the product of Dean Knuth.  Knuth was also the lead designer and proponent of the Slope System while he was at the USGA.   The Golf Digest handicap will have all of the same flaws Knuth noted in his arguments supporting the Slope System. Knuth may have believed the casual player mostly plays the same course so “portability” is not all that important.  In many cases, this is not an unreasonable assumption.
Different Equitable Stroke Control(ESC)l Procedures – The Golf Digest handicap system limits a player to a net double bogey.  The USGA sets limits on hole scores depending a a player’s handicap.  Sometimes the Golf Digest ESC is more penal, and at other times the USGA ESC is more penal.  Take a 15 handicap for example.  The USGA allows him a maximum of 7 strokes on a par 5.  If he strokes, on this hole, however, Golf Digest allows 8 strokes.  On a par three, the USGA allows a 7strokes, while if the player doesn’t stroke Golf digest only allows 5 strokes.  The differences in strokes would probably even out, so the two  ESCs should not result in significantly different adjusted scores.
Differing Sample Sizes – The USGA takes the average of the ten best differentials out of the last 20 and then multiplies by .96 (the Bonus for Excellence).  Golf Digest takes the average of a player’s second, third, and fourth-best scores out of the last ten.  Without submitting the proof, the average computed by both methods will be similar. 

In summary, the Golf Digest handicap is a reasonable estimate of a player’s USGA handicap except for the omission of the Slope Rating.  If a player plays most often at the same course, the Slope Rating loses importance and the two handicap systems yield approximately the same result. 





[1] The differences between the Golf Digest and United States Golf Association handicaps are detailed in the Appendix.  In many instances, the Golf Digest handicap will approximate the USGA handicap.  It is not a replica, however, and cannot be considered equivalent for any serious competition.  

Thursday, April 16, 2015

The Case for Eliminating Decision 3-5/2 from the USGA Handicap System

Decision 3-5/2 of the USGA Handicap System 2012-2015 states a competition that does not adjust handicaps in accordance with Section 3-5 waives a Rule of Golf.   It is not clear which rule is being waived.  Nor is it clear any penalty would be assessed for conducting a competition that did not follow Section 3-5.  A rule without sanctions is not a rule, but general guidance.  The case for changing or eliminating Decision 3-5/2 is made below. 

Here is how the decision reads presently at www.usga.org:

3-5/2 – Golf Club Chooses Not to Follow Section 3-5 of the USGA Handicap System
Q:  May golf clubs choose not to follow Section 3-5 of "The USGA Handicap System" manual if the club's groups are competing from different tees?

A:  No. Not applying Section 3-5 of The "USGA Handicap System" when players are competing from different tees would be waiving a Rule of Golf, and the Committee in charge of a competition does not have the authority to waive a Rule of Golf.

Note, the USGA no longer states which Rule of Golf is waived when Section 3-5 is not followed.  In the printed edition of the Handicap System, the reader was referred to “Rules of Golf,” Decision 6-2/1.  That decision is shown below:

6-2/1 Meaning of "Handicap"
Q. Under a handicapping system where the player has to adjust his handicap in accordance with the rating for the course he is playing, a player's handicap before adjustment is 4.8. After applying the appropriate adjustment for the course and the tees to be used for that competition, the player's handicap is 6. Which is his "handicap" for the purposes of Rule 6-2?
A. 6. In a stroke-play competition the player must ensure that the handicap for the course that he is to play and the tees to be used is recorded on his score card when it is returned to the Committee.

First, how does a player have a 4.8 handicap?  Handicaps are integers.[1]  It is probable the USGA meant a player had an Index of 4.8 and not a handicap of 4.8.  The probable intent of this decision was to ensure the player calculated his handicap correctly based on the Slope Rating of the course to be played—i.e., the player could not meet the requirement of Rule 6-2 by recording his correct Index, but an incorrect Course Handicap.  Second, how does ignoring Section 3-5 violate this rule?   If a player does not record his handicap on his scorecard or reports a handicap higher than to which he is entitled, he is disqualified under Rule 6-2.  But if the players from the tees with the higher course rating fail to add additional strokes to their handicap, there would not be a violation of Rule 6-2.  More importantly, it does not appear to be the player’s responsibility to make the Section 3-5 adjustment.  That is the duty of the Committee as inferred from Decision 6-2b/0.5 of the Rules of Golf:

6-2b/0.5 Meaning of "Handicap" When Full Handicap Not Used

Q.  It is the condition of a stroke-play competition (e.g., four-ball) that players will not receive their full handicap allowances. Under Rule 6-2b, what is the player responsible for recording on his score card?
A.  He must record his full handicap. It is the Committee's responsibility to apply the condition of competition to adjust his handicap.

Since the Committee assigned the tournament handicaps with no Section 3-5 adjustment, no players are at fault and no penalty can be assigned.

Scott Hovde of the USGA attempted to defend Decision 3-5/2 when he wrote:[2]

“The key here is that if a competition is played under the Rules of Golf, the committee cannot waive a Rule of Golf (they do have the option to not play under the Rules of Golf).  There are no specific penalty strokes assessed when a committee decides to waive a Rule of Golf…no different than if they told competitors to play OB as a lateral hazard or allow for grounding clubs in a hazard.  It is when the players are then forced to not play by the Rules of Golf (in this case, potentially an incorrect handicap, which may result in a DQ per Decision 6-2b/3.5) that is the issue.  Basically the committee (club) is knowingly putting players in a position that, if playing by the Rules of Golf, would be in conflict with the Rules of Golf.”

Hovde is arguing that 1) a Committee states no Sec. 3-5 adjustment will be made, 2) the player enters his handicap accordingly, and 3) the Committee disqualifies the player for following the Committee’s instructions.  This would be both bizarre and highly unlikely.    

The USGA took a different path when it was asked if a match at full handicap was equitable (See Decision 9-4a/1 of The USGA Handicap System).  The answer was no.  Decision 3-5/2 should reflect the same reasoning (i.e., comment on the equity and not the legality of ignoring Section 3-5) or better yet be eliminated.[3]  

Decision 3-5/2 was added in 2006.  That means ignoring Section 3-5 before 2006 was not waiving a Rule of Golf.  I suspect nothing in the Rules of Golf was changed in 2006 that necessitated Decision 3/5-2.  More probably, an advocate of Section 3-5 pushed for the current language in an attempt to promote wider acceptance of the adjustment.  But as Dean Knuth wrote, Rules of Golf should not be used as a hammer within the Handicap System.[4]  The USGA should educate and not mandate Committees on how to run an equitable tournament—i.e., when Sec. 3-5 should be employed and when it should be avoided.  Moreover, since compliance to Section 3-5 is close to universal, Decision 3-5/2 serves no useful purpose and could be eliminated without consequence.



[1] The CONGU Unified Handicapping System does have an “Exact Handicap” which is expressed to the nearest tenth.  A player in the CONGU System, however, does not adjust his handicap in accordance with the rating for the course and is therefore unaffected by Decision 6-2/1.
[2] E-mail to author, April 8, 2015.
[3] Section 9-4 of the Handicap System does say players must (emphasis added) apply the difference in USGA Course Ratings from the tees played.”   It would be more consistent with the rest of Section 9-4 to say players should apply the difference.  The USGA overuses the term “must.” Section 3-5 states the adjustment must be added to the higher-rated tee players’ Course Handicap. Later in the Section 3 Decisions, it is stated the Committee could subtract the adjustment from the handicaps of the players competing from the lower-rated set of tees.  The use of “must” implies necessity which is lacking in this case.
[4] Letter to the USGA from Dean Knuth, former director of Handicapping at the USGA, January 18, 2001 as presented at www.popeofslope.com.

Friday, December 5, 2014

The Pacific Amateur Golf Tournament: If you go…

The Pacific Amateur (Pac-Am) golf tournament is held in Bend, Oregon every year.  It is run by the Central Oregon Visitors Association (COVA) to promote tourism in the shoulder season between golf and skiing.  If you go, you can expect good golf courses, good food, and a great selection of ales from Bend’s many breweries.  What you cannot expect is an equitable competition.

The Pac-Am attracts approximately 400 golfers each year and they compete in flights based on age, sex, and handicap.   The typical flight has 24 players.  After three rounds, the top four players in each flight compete in the finals at the Crosswater Course at the Sunriver Resort.

With so many golfers, it is likely that a few will not be in strict adherence to the USGA Handicap System. The Pac-Am assures its participants that they will have to pass a handicap background check before they are allowed to enter.  Here are a few warnings from the Pac-Am website: 

Any unusual posting procedures, such as ceasing to post scores for a period leading up to the event, may be grounds for disqualification.  Any participant found using a fraudulent Handicap will be expelled from the tournament and all fees will be forfeited.

Participants in the competitive net divisions will compete using an assigned Tournament Handicap.  The participant will need to provide a complete scoring history to the Handicap Committee.  This handicap is calculated using one to two methods.  The committee may assign a handicap from a previous month if it deems the participant’s historical handicap is a better representation of scoring potential.  (Alternatively), the Tournament Handicap can be calculated by using past Pac-Am tournament scores and scores from other tournaments.  Tournament scores (especially those from the Pac-Am) are weighted more heavily in the calculation to help prevent golfers from having “repeat career round” during tournaments.

The vetting procedure sounds so strict that no sandbagger could make it through.  In truth, the Pac-Am’s policy is essentially a paper tiger.  With a limited staff, the Tournament Committee cannot check the bona fides of all entrants.  Basically, if your entry check clears, you are in.
    
The 2014 Pac-Am demonstrated the Tournament Committee’s inability to conduct an equitable tournament.  In this tournament, the same player was a repeat winner of the over-all net competition. The Bend Bulletin (September 26, 2014) in an act of journalistic naiveté extolled the accomplishment.  Asked to explain his unlikely performance, the player said  “I really can’t explain it.  I love the course and I think playing four, five or six days in a row just helps me swing better.”  The Tournament Committee was equally impressed and featured the winner’s picture on its website along with an article on the remarkable accomplishment of being the first repeat winner in the Tournament’s history.

No one seemed to ask the obvious question “Is the player’s handicap legitimate?” [1] Though the player was from Washington State, he did not have a handicap with any golf club belonging to the Washington State Golf Association.  When this was brought to the attention of COVA, it responded:

We are happy to provide you with (the player’s) USGA handicap card, with his index dated 9/15/2014, issued by his home course.

COVA was incorrect when it wrote the player’s index was issued by his home course (emphasis added).  His index was issued by an affiliate club (i.e., no course) through a company named MyScorecard.  MyScorecard sells a handicapping service for $14.95 a year.   Supposedly clubs formed under the aegis of MyScorecard have peer review.  But this is in theory only.  In practice, I bought a MyScorecard index that had no relationship to my potential ability.  I never received a query from my alleged handicap chairman who could possibly be a figment of someone’s imagination.
  
Even though the lack of peer review makes it is easy to cheat with MyScorecard, it does not necessarily follow that this player cheated.  To determine the authenticity of the index, it is necessary to examine his posted scores.  Here is what that examination revealed:

1. The player never posted a score from Crosswater even though he shot two net 66s in winning the Pac-Am finals in 2013 and 2014.
2. He never posted any round as a T-Score even though the Pac-Am Tournament Committee was supposedly to weight these scores heavily in arriving at the player’s tournament handicap.
3. The player played at a higher index in 2014 than in 2013 even though he won the tournament in 2013.  Apparently the Pac-Am Tournament Committee is not as vigilant in adjusting handicaps based on past performance as its website claims.

The missing 2013 tournament score (i.e., had it been posted it would have been in the last twenty scores and used in calculating the player’s index used for the 2014 tournament) means the player’s handicap was fraudulent and he should have been stripped of his title as the Pac-Am rules stipulate.  This did not happen.  COVA continued to defend the player’s performance as not extraordinary.  By any measure, however, the performance was extraordinary.  First, the player had to finish in the top four of his flight.  The probability of doing this is 1/6.  Then he had to win the finals against approximately 40 competitors.  The probability of doing this is 1/40.  The probability of doing this twice in a row is 1/57,600.  Even the probability of a defending champion repeating is 1/240—i.e., highly unlikely.

COVA did not hand down a harsh verdict on this player’s performance, and the reason is fairly clear.   To do so would reveal handicaps are not getting the close scrutiny the Pac-Am claims.  Prospective players could be turned off and participation could be reduced if they believed the tournament was not an equitable competition.   Since COVA’s real purpose is to fill motel rooms (from which it gets a percentage of the Transient Occupancy Tax), advertising the misconduct of the player and the ineffectiveness of its staff would not be in its interest.  Best just to forget about it and hope the player does not come back and “threepeat.”














[1] Dean Knuth, former Senior Director of Handicapping of the USGA, did pioneering work on the probability of exceptional scores.—see www.popeoftheslope.com.  Knuth recognized the weakness of the USGA’s handicap system in catching flagrant sandbaggers.  He invented the Knuth Point System where a player’s handicap is reduced based on what he wins and not on what he scores.