Showing posts with label Golf Digest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Golf Digest. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2015

The Golf Digest Handicap: Why Bother?

Golf Digest started offering a handicap service in 2013.  The question is “Why bother to offer or get a Golf Digest handicap?”  Golf Digest was once the flagship magazine of the golf community.  It has been listing badly as of late.  It is hard to be current when you only publish once a month.  Its time lapsed photography used for instruction seems antiquated in today’s internet and iphone world.  In an effort to be relevant, the editor’s decided Golf Digest should become hip – the magazine for millennials.  The magazine recently featured articles about the best looking girlfriends on Tour, the joy of playing shirtless, the thrill of having sex on the golf course, and a cover story on Paulina Gretsky—golf’s equivalent of a  Kardashian.  It appears Golf Digest has traded its dignity for stagnant circulation at best.

The Golf Digest handicap may be a gesture of atonement for its sophomoric behavior.   If public service was the motive, however, the Golf Digest handicap would have to have some value for there to be absolution. Unfortunately, the Golf Digest handicap is of little benefit to the player for the following reasons:

Not Universal – For a handicap system to be effective, competing players must use the same handicap system.  Golf Digest argues its handicap “allows golfers of all skill levels to compete against one another fairly.”  This assumes other players have a Golf Digest handicap which is very unlikely. If the other players have USGA handicaps, they would probably look upon your Golf Digest handicap like a cashier looks upon a $3 bill.[1] 
No Peer Review – An absolute necessity for a handicap system is peer review.  Peer review gives some assurance (maybe p=.85) a handicap is a true measure of a player’s potential. Peer review is absent from the Golf Digest handicap system. 
Oversold – Golf Digest argues its handicap is “a way to determine where your game needs the most help.”  Handicap systems, however, can identify a bad golfer but not pinpoint why he is bad.  At best, the Golf Digest handicap can put you in a class of players (e.g. 20+ handicap) who usually have these deficiencies (e.g., sliced drives, inadequate short game).  Since players are typically aware of their weaknesses, it is unlikely the Golf Digest handicap will provide any new information.
Absence of Slope Rating – The Golf Digest Handicap was developed by Dean Knuth, former Director of Handicapping at the USGA, who was responsible for the adoption of the Slope System.  Knuth argues the Golf Digest handicap is fair and “portable.”  His statement goes against 30 years of arguments made by himself and the USGA proclaiming only the Slope System can make handicaps portable.   If you are a muni player (Slope Rating = 110) and Jerry Tarde, Managing Editor of Golf Digest, asks you to be his guest at Pine Valley (Slope Rating = 155), you will be at a serious disadvantage with your Golf Digest handicap. 
Measure of Progress – The Golf Digest handicap does let a player measure how his performance changes over time.  A player with a minimal knowledge of spreadsheets, however, can track a USGA handicap using actual Course and Slope Ratings.  If that is too difficult, the player can track his differential (Adjusted Score – USGA Course Rating) and get essentially the same information provided by the Golf Digest handicap. 

A better explanation than public service for the free handicap is Golf Digest’s desire to increase visits to its website.  Golf Digest has been giving away “free stuff” for years in hopes of stemming subscriber defections.  For example, it has tie-in sales where the magazine is given away if another product is purchased—e.g., a golf association membership or a large purchase at a golf store.  (Note: About 25 percent of Golf digest’s circulation is listed as “free or nominal rate distribution.”)  Now it is giving away a free handicap in hopes of harvesting the player’s e-mail address or having him click on an ad that appears on the posting sheet.
 
The Golf Digest handicap is aimed at the universe of players who 1) Are not serious enough about the game to get a USGA handicap,  2) Are serious enough to want to improve their game, and 3) Are aware of the existence of the Golf Digest handicap.  This should be a very small population indeed.   Golf Digest’s gambit should fail as both a marketing ploy and as a viable handicap.  To answer the title question of this post, neither the magazine nor the player should bother with the Golf Digest handicap.
 
Appendix
The USGA vs. Golf Digest Handicap

For legal reasons, Golf Digest could not use the USGA handicap formula.   The Golf Digest handicap differs from the USGA handicap in the following four ways:

1. The Course Rating is estimated solely as a function of yardage.
2. There is no Slope Rating.
3. Different equitable stroke control procedures.
4. The sample size of scores is smaller.

Each of these differences affects the difference between a USGA and Golf Digest handicap:

Course Rating formulae – The USGA’s course rating formula for men is:

                Course Rating(USGA) = Yardage/220 +40.9 + SOV
                                                 SOV= Scratch Obstacle Value
The Golf Digest formula for the Course Rating is:
                Course Rating(GD) = Yardage/200 +39

For all courses greater than 4200 yards, the Course Rating(GD) will be larger than the yardage component of the  Course Rating(USGA).  This difference could be a proxy for SOV which the Course Rating(GD) does not explicitly incorporate.  Instead, it could be assuming the SOV is an increasing function of yardage.
This adjustment for omitting the SOV may not be sufficient.  The table below shows the USGA and Golf Digest Course Ratings for a selection of courses in Southern California.  The USGA Course Rating is higher is 6 of the 7 cases.  Therefore, the Golf Digest Course Rating formula would, on average, yield a slightly higher handicap than the USGA Course Rating formula.    

Table
USGA and Golf Digest Course Ratings

Course(Tee)
Yardage
USGA Rating
Golf Digest Rating
Difference
Los Angeles CC(White)
6486
72.4
71.4
+1.0
Riviera(White)
6531
72.2
71.7
+0.5
Torrey Pines South(White)
6628
73.1
72.1
+1.0
PGA West Stadium(White)
6166
70.2
69.8
+0.4
Rancho La Quinta Jones(White)
5986
68.6
68.9
-0.3
Wilshire CC(Blue)
6265
70.7
70.3
+.04
Bel Air CC(White)
6235
71.0
70.2
+0.8

Absence of the Slope Rating – The Golf Digest Handicap system is the product of Dean Knuth.  Knuth was also the lead designer and proponent of the Slope System while he was at the USGA.   The Golf Digest handicap will have all of the same flaws Knuth noted in his arguments supporting the Slope System. Knuth may have believed the casual player mostly plays the same course so “portability” is not all that important.  In many cases, this is not an unreasonable assumption.
Different Equitable Stroke Control(ESC)l Procedures – The Golf Digest handicap system limits a player to a net double bogey.  The USGA sets limits on hole scores depending a a player’s handicap.  Sometimes the Golf Digest ESC is more penal, and at other times the USGA ESC is more penal.  Take a 15 handicap for example.  The USGA allows him a maximum of 7 strokes on a par 5.  If he strokes, on this hole, however, Golf Digest allows 8 strokes.  On a par three, the USGA allows a 7strokes, while if the player doesn’t stroke Golf digest only allows 5 strokes.  The differences in strokes would probably even out, so the two  ESCs should not result in significantly different adjusted scores.
Differing Sample Sizes – The USGA takes the average of the ten best differentials out of the last 20 and then multiplies by .96 (the Bonus for Excellence).  Golf Digest takes the average of a player’s second, third, and fourth-best scores out of the last ten.  Without submitting the proof, the average computed by both methods will be similar. 

In summary, the Golf Digest handicap is a reasonable estimate of a player’s USGA handicap except for the omission of the Slope Rating.  If a player plays most often at the same course, the Slope Rating loses importance and the two handicap systems yield approximately the same result. 





[1] The differences between the Golf Digest and United States Golf Association handicaps are detailed in the Appendix.  In many instances, the Golf Digest handicap will approximate the USGA handicap.  It is not a replica, however, and cannot be considered equivalent for any serious competition.  

Friday, February 22, 2013

Equitable Stroke Control - A Postmortem


          The previous post, What Does the New Equitable Stroke Control Mean for Golf?,  struck a responsive chord at Golf Digest.  Jerry Tarde, editor of Golf Digest, lifted many parts of the paper for his column entitled “A formula for slow play and higher scores.”[1]  Tarde used the material without either attribution or compensation (if you don’t count an autographed copy of a book he had ghost written for Sam Snead).
I did not take offense, however, for here was a major golf publication at least questioning the USGA.  I was further encouraged when Golf Digest implied it would be conducting an independent review of ESC93.  In a letter to Mr. Tarde, I urged:

"Golf Digest to demand to see the three studies the USGA claimed supported  ESC93. I believe you will find that while the USGA will trumpet the findings of studies supporting their position, they will not make these studies available for peer review.  I hope you will be made privy to these studies so Golf Digest could come to an independent and informed evaluation of the new ESC procedure. [2]

            I was to be greatly disappointed by Golf Digest’s effort.  Golf Digest assigned the story to Guy Yocom.  Yocom did not review any USGA study, and his article was simply a listing of unchallenged replies by Dean Knuth, Director of Handicapping for the USGA.[3]  Yocom’s article lacked insight and demonstrated an interview style better suited to People Magazine.  An example will demonstrate Yocom’s deficiency:

                        Question by Yocom: Since even low handicappers now can score a 6 on a par 3, won’t this be a boon for sandbaggers?

                        Knuth: No…Par 3s are where golfers receive the fewest number of handicap   strokes, where 99 percent of players are likely to try their hardest to score well.

            Now there are two problems with Knuth’s reply.  First, there is no reason to believe a golfer’s effort on a hole is related to whether he gets a handicap stroke.  Second, and more importantly, Knuth is charging that 99 percent of all golfers are unethical since they violate the basic precept of the handicap system that “every player will endeavor to make the best score he can at each hole.”[4]  Knuth’s defense rests on the lack of integrity of the American golfer.  Poor Yocom did not identify either problem.[5]
            Yocom did a follow-up article that was equally unsatisfactory.  He even made a small technical error in trying to explain why the ESC was changed.  When I pointed out the error, it was apparently too much for Yocom.  He wrote:

                       "Just a crazy, giddy guess on my part, but is there a Dealey Plaza (where you live)…Has your company conducted any research on the subject (ESC).  I would be glad to look it over, as you must have some basis for your persistent opinion opposing the new ESC."[6]

I had to respond in a letter to Jerry Tarde:[7]

                       "Though he does not write with great clarity, Yocom seems to liken me to Lee  Harvey Oswald.  I find this personally offensive and beyond the pale of  responsible debate.  It is unfortunate when a representative of your fine magazine does not bring intelligence or insight to an issue, but only personal invective.

                        Mr. Yocom claims that I oppose ESC.  He apparently had not read my paper.  What I oppose is change that does not represent progress.  I do not believe the USGA proved any substantive benefit from the new ESC…The new ESC may be a success as (the USGA) claims.  That judgment, however, should have rested upon an independent evaluation of the data Yocom had promised in March.  Yocom’s January article failed to deliver on that promise."

            The net result was Yocom still gets a press pass to the U.S. Open, and I canceled my subscription to Golf digest.
Despite the USGA claims of great support, ESC93 did not make many people happy.  The USGA was to try a different ESC in 1997.  Currently, ESC consists of a hybrid system.  Low handicappers are now allowed to take a double bogey on any hole.  This was in answer to the many complaints that taking a 6 on a par five was not equitable.  All handicaps of ten and above have the same limits as ESC93.  No research was ever published on why low handicap players should be treated differently than high handicapped players.  It appears the USGA Handicap Procedure Committee was only responding to a political problem with low handicapped players rather than seeking a just solution to the ESC problem.  Given the track history of this most political institution, such a resolution should come as no surprise.




[1] Jerry Tarde, “A formula for slow play and higher scores,” Golf Digest, Trumbull, CT, June 1993.
[2] Letter from the author to Jerry Tarde, January 15, 1993.
[3] Guy Yocom, “Why your handicap will change this year,” Golf Digest, Trumbull, CT, March 1993
[4] USGA Handicap Manual, p. 1
[5] Yocom has no technical background and could not review any studies if the USGA gave them to him.  His principle background is that of ghost writer.  He wrote a book with Corey Pavin on shotmaking shortly before Mr. Pavin’s career started to ebb.  Therefore, the lack of analysis and evaluation is the fault of those at Golf Digest who assigned Yocom to this inquiry.
[6] Letter to the author from Guy Yocom, December 15, 1993
[7] Letter from the author to Jerry Tarde, December 27, 1993.