Monday, May 21, 2018

Quota System Vs. Stableford System



The Quota System and the Stableford System are two common methods for tournament scoring.  In the Quota System a player is given a quota equal to 36 minus his handicap (e.g., a 15 handicap would have a quota of 21).  As shown in the table below, a player earns points based on his gross score on each hole.  A player’s tournament score is the total of points earned minus his quota.  For example, if a player earned 24 points with a quota of 21, his tournament score would be +3.  In the Stableford System, a player earns points on his net score as shown in the table. The total number of points earned is his tournament score.

Table
Points for Quota System and Stableford System

Quota System
Stableford System
Gross Double Eagle
5
Net Double Eagle
5
Gross Eagle
4
Net Eagle
4
Gross Birdie
3
Net Birdie
3
Gross Par
2
Net Par
2
Gross Bogey
1
Net Bogey
1
Gross Double Bogey
0
Net Double Bogey
0

It would seem a system based on gross scores would not necessarily produce the same winners as one based on net scores.  A closer analysis reveals that is not the case except in one instance.  (For simplicity, eagles and double eagles have been excluded from the proof.)
The Quota System is described by:

                 Eq. 1)           Q= 3∙(Xs + Xn) + 2∙ (Ps + Pn) +1∙(Bs +Bn) – (36-H)

Where,
Q= Quota Score
Xs = Number of Birdies on stroke holes
Xn = Number of Birdies on non-stroke holes
Ps = Number of Pars on stroke holes
Pn = Number of Pars on non-stroke holes
Bs = Number of Bogeys on stroke holes
Bn = Number of Bogeys on non-stroke holes

The Stableford System is described by:

Eq. 2)      S = 4∙Xs + 3∙Xn + 3∙Ps +2∙Pn + 2∙Bs + 1∙Bn + 1∙Ds + 0∙Dn + 0∙Ts

Where,
              S = Stableford Score
              Ds =   Number of Double Bogeys on stroke hole
              Dn = Number of Double Bogeys on non-stroke hole
              Ts = Number of Triple Bogeys on stroke holes

Now a player’s handicap must equal:

Eq. 3)     H = Xs +Ps + Bs + Ds +Ts

Substituting equation 3) into equation 2 a player's Stableford Score is:

Eq. 4)    S = H + 3∙Xs + 3Xn + 2∙Ps + 2∙Pn + 1∙Bs +1∙Bn + 1∙Ds + 0∙Dn + 0∙Ts

The difference between a player's Stableford score and his Quota score is shown in equation 5):

              Eq. 5)    S – Q = H + 3∙(Xs + Xn) 2∙(Ps + Pn) + 1∙(Bs +Bn) – (3∙(Xs +Xn) + 2∙(Ps + Pn) + 1∙(Bs +Bn) + 1∙Ds +       
                                              Ts - (36 – H)

                      = 36 - Ts

In summary, a player’s Stableford score will be 36 points higher than his Quota score minus the number of holes where a player scored a triple bogey on a stroke hole.  The appendix gives an example that includes the case where a player’s score is his adjusted gross score minus his handicap.  Where no player scores a triple bogey with a stroke (i.e., Ts=0) all three scoring system yield the same order of finish and margin of victory. 

When one player has a triple bogey instead of a double bogey on a stroke hole stroke (player D on the par 4 ninth hole), his Quota score  remains unchanged.  His Stableford score is reduced by one point and his adjusted score minus his handicap is increased by one.  The Quota System gives a slight edge to players more likely to have a triple bogey.

 Which scoring system should be preferred?  Since a player must post his adjusted score, a player’s adjusted score minus his handicap would seem to be the simplest.  Under the World Handicap system, the Adjusted score minus handicap will always produce the same results as the Stableford System.  A player’s adjusted score on a par 72 course is ((72 + (36-Stableford Points) + Handicap). Therefore, the Stableford System is acceptable since it is easy to use and generates a players adjusted score.  It is not possible to translate a Quota Score to a player’s adjusted score.  This means a player should also keep his adjusted score as well as his Quota Score. Having to keep two sets of scores should eliminate the Quota System from consideration.

Appendix
Scores Without Triple Bogeys with a Stroke

Adjusted Score – Course Handicap

P
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Tot
Score
A(8)
5*
4
5*
5*
6*
5*
4*
6*
5*
45
37
B(6)
5*
4
5*
3
5*
4
5*
5*
5*
41
35
C(6)
5*
5
6*
3
5*
6
4*
6*
4*
44
38
D(7)
5*
4
6*
2
5*
3*
4*
6*
6*
41
34
S
Stableford

P(H)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Score
A(8)
2
1
3
1
1
2
3
2
2
17
B(6)
2
1
3
2
2
2
2
3
2
19
C(6)
2
0
2
2
2
0
3
2
3
16
D(7)
2
1
2
3
2
4
3
2
0 20

Quota

P(H)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Score
A(8)
1
1
2
0
0
1
2
1
1
9-10=-1
B(6)
1
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
13-12-=1
C(6)
1
0
1
2
1
0
2
1
2
10-12=-2
D(7)
1
1
1
3
1
3
2
1
0
13-11=2


Scores with Triple Bogeys with a Stroke
(Player D on hole No. 9)

Adjusted Score – Course Handicap

P(H)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Tot
Score
A(8)
5*
4
5*
5*
6*
5*
4*
6*
5*
45
37
B(6)
5*
4
5*
3
5*
4
5*
5*
5*
41
35
C(6)
5*
5
6*
3
5*
6
4*
6*
4*
44
38
D(7)
5*
4
6*
2
5*
3*
4*
6*
7*
42
35

Stableford
Stableford
P(H)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Score
A(8)
2
1
3
1
1
2
3
2
2
17
B(6)
2
1
3
2
2
2
2
3
2
19
C(6)
2
0
2
2
2
0
3
2
3
16
D(7)
2
1
2
3
2
4
3
2
0
19

Quota

P(H)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Score
A(8)
1
1
2
0
0
1
2
1
1
9-10=-1
B(6)
1
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
13-12=1
C(6)
1
0
1
2
1
0
2
1
2
10-12=-2
D(7)
1
1
1
3
1
3
2
1
0
13-11=2



Tuesday, March 27, 2018

Should the Wall Street Journal Cover Golf?

This blog has been critical of the Wall Street Journal's (WSJ) golf columns.  John Paul Newport, the Journal's first golf columnist, was low hanging fruit. His columns were often fatuous (see his column on a day with Donald Trump) and frequently filled with errors.  Newport was replaced by Brian Costa, but it would be hard to notice any change unless you read the byline.  In Costa's latest column (Patrick Reed Wins the Masters, April 9, 2018), he writes:

Fowler added more late pressure to Reed by making a birdie on the 17th hole to cut his lead to one. 

In fact, Fowler made a birdie on the 18th hole not the 17th hole.  How do such errors get by the editors?  An examination of how a previous error was treated by the staff at the WSJ provides a clue.

The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) recently ran an article that referred to Tony Romo as having a 0.3 Handicap.  Of course no one has a 0.3 "handicap," but it was a small error and not worthy of correction. The next day, however, the WSJ ran a correction that noted  Romo actually had a +0.3 handicap and not a 0.3 handicap. If the WSJ bothers to make a correction, it should get it right.  I sent the following correction to the editor at the WSJ:

Your correction is still in error.  Tony Romo has a +0.3 Handicap Index not a +0.3 Handicap.  A player's Course Handicap is determined by multiplying his Index by the Course Slope Rating/113 and rounding the product to the nearest integer.  A player's handicap is always an integer.  Your golf writer should have known this.  

I expected the WSJ to acknowledge the error and pledge not to do it again.  Instead, the editor (Tim Carroll) defended the error with rather curious reasoning:


Thank you for your email.

While the term "handicap index" is the one used by the USGA and in the exacting Rules of Golf, it is not the term in general use. In 50 years of playing golf, including with many USGA officials, I am not sure anyone has ever asked me on the first tee for my "handicap index."

The Wall Street Journal writes for that general readership and we feel that by using the technical term we could be raising more questions than answering in readers' minds. (Note: When Carroll writes "that general readership" he implies there is more than one general readership. Apparently, he does not do a careful edit of his own writings.)

The first problem with the response is the term "Handicap Index" does not appear in the Rules of Golf as the editor states. (Perhaps his fact-checker was on vacation). The term Index is also not so arcane that it is use is restricted to the USGA.  If you enter any tournament, the tournament committee will ask for your Handicap Index and not your Handicap. Every player should know his or her Handicap Index which is the measure of a player's ability and is necessary to calculate his Course Handicap. 

The fact the editor has played with USGA officials is supposed to lend credibility to his argument, but only demonstrates an unbecoming degree of pomposity.   The editor is probably right that no one has asked for his handicap index in 50 years.  There are two possible reasons for this.  First, for the first 19 years of his playing career there was no Slope System and hence no Handicap Index. Second, his playing partners probably assumed the editor checked his Handicap Index and calculated his Course Handicap before coming to the first tee.

The editor's last defense is  WSJ readers lack the sophistication to understand the nuances of the handicap system.  That argument could be used if the article was about Bitcoin and blockchain technology.  Since the error in question appeared in the WSJ's golf column, it is probable most readers were golfers and familiar with the term Handicap Index. To dumb down the article was not necessary, but it was condescending.

The probable cause of the many errors in the golf columns is that the editors lack sufficient knowledge to do their job well.  Can you imagine Golfweek, Golf Digest, or Links getting mixed up about which hole was birdied?  If the WSJ is going to write about golf it should concentrate on what it knows best, the financial side. If it is merely going to report who won and regurgitate remarks from the press briefing, it is a waste of the WSJ's unique talent. 



     






Monday, July 10, 2017

Links Magazine’s Take on Who Should Pay for USGA National Championships

An article in Links Magazine (Schupak, Adam, “Pay to Play,” Summer 2017) asked who should pay the costs incurred in hosting a USGA National Championship?   The article argues the USGA should ease the burden on host clubs by increasing its subsidy to tournaments.  The argument however is not supported by cogent reasoning or empirical analysis.  There is no doubt the costs and revenues of USGA tournaments are in need of review.  This article does not provide that examination as explained below. 
    
The article focused on the costs incurred by the 2015 Men’s Mid-Amateur Championship held at the John’s Island Club in Florida.  It also mentioned a couple of other tournament, but did not describe those in depth.  Such a small sample size limits the credibility of the article’s position.  The article did state the 2013 Men’s Mid-Amateur cost the Country Club of Birmingham $300,000, but two years later John’s Island Club spent $650,000. The article is silent on what caused the $350,000 increase in costs.  It would have been important to review the contract between the USGA and John’s Island Club to determine which expenses were required by the USGA and which were optional expenses incurred at the Club’s discretion.

The article describes the current state of hosting costs:

The cost of running even one of the USGA’s 10 amateur championships has grown exponentially.  The starting price can be as modest as roughly $150,000 for the U.S. Women’s Mid-Amateur, balloons to $750,000 for the Walker Cup, and gets close to $1 million for the U.S. Amateur when a larger footprint for worldwide media an television compounds are factored in.

There is no reference to where these cost numbers come from.  This is a serious omission since the high costs are an essential part of the argument for increased USGA financial support.  If high costs are not documented, the article’s thesis cannot be proven.

The costs are purported to have risen exponentially, but the article only presents longitudinal data for the Gold Mountain Golf Club in Washington.  The cost of the Amateur Public Links was $150,000 in 2006.  Five years later the cost was $180,000 for the 2011 U.S. Junior Amateur.  That is only a 4 percent annual increase in current dollars and less than that in real dollars (i.e., costs adjusted for inflation).   The example from Gold Mountain was presented to demonstrate the escalating costs, but actually did just the opposite.

Now costs may have risen dramatically at other events or in years past 2011.  The article, however, presents no evidence to that effect or any explanation of why costs have exploded.  Has the USGA placed more requirements on the host club?  Or have host clubs increased the costs by trying to one-up previous host clubs?   These are important questions that go unanswered.

The article assumes the USGA places an inequitable burden on host clubs and suggests the USGA should pay more of the cost.   Mark Mulvoy, Chairman of the John’s Island Championship Committee makes the following argument:

Why does a non-profit (the USGA) have over $300 million in the bank?  Our members help fund educational programs and build museums and wings of hospitals.

Mulvoy’s complaint is not compelling.  The combined net worth of the members of the John’s Island Club dwarfs the USGA’s cash reserve. So why should the USGA subsidize the top 1 percent on the economic ladder?  It does not help matters that Mulvoy spent $100,000 on a “lavish gala” (as described in the local paper) for former Mid-Amateur champions in February 2016 when the tournament was still seven months away.   In the end, the John’s Island Club Mid-Amateur Committee only donated $7,500 to a junior golf organization.
   
Lacking any empirical evidence to support the article’s thesis, the author went to David Fay, former Executive Director of the USGA for support.  Fay came up with a platitudinous solution to a problem that may not exist.  Fay suggested the USGA should guarantee that no club that hosts one of its championships is ever put in a financial bind.  Fay’s proposal has two serious flaws.  First, if the USGA guarantees no financial harm it creates a moral hazard.  That is, clubs would not have an incentive to guard against risk because they would be protected from the consequences.  Second, Fay’s proposal would require the USGA to approve and monitor expenses.  If the USGA is to ensure host club is not put in dire financial straits, it must make sure the expenses are both reasonable (e.g., no strippers for the after-party) and legitimate (i.e., no charging the tournament account for steak when hot dogs are served).  This is essentially a forensic accounting exercise the USGA should avoid.

If the article’s thesis is correct and more USGA financial support is required, there should be a shortage of clubs vying to host tournaments.  This is not the case as the article concludes:

…Despite the watered down media exposure and fan interest, and overall lack of attention, top clubs continue to line up to host the USGA’s non-remunerative championships…

In essence, there does not appear to be a problem with the USGA’s current level of financial support.   This raises the question of why the article was written.  Was it to be a paean to the 2015 Mid-Amateur (Comments such as “even the Russian judge would give it a 9.9,” and”Sammy Schmitz made a stunning hole-in-one” were not essential to the article’s objective and should have been removed in editing)?  Was it to lay the blame on the USGA rather than on tournament director Mulvoy for the budget overrun?  Was it to cajole the USGA into increasing the subsidy to a future tournament where members of the Links editorial staff have an interest?  The answers to these questions are not known.  What is known is the article does not meet the high editorial standards associated with Links,