Friday, May 15, 2015

Handicap Allowances for Eclectic Golf Tournaments

In an eclectic golf tournament, players play the same course more than once and select the best score on each hole as the score for the competition.  If played a full handicap, the competition would favor the high handicap player.  To demonstrate this, assume two players have the probabilities for scoring shown in
Table 1.

Table 1
Probability of Scoring Relative to Par on Each Hole


Handicap
Score Relative to Par
-1
0
+1
+2
Low Handicap
.1
.8
.1
.0
High Handicap
.0
.2
.6
.2

Over eighteen holes, the low handicap player would average even par.  The high handicap player would average 18 over par for a difference between players of 18 strokes.    There handicaps would be approximately 18 strokes different.[1]  Now assume each player is allowed to play two rounds and take his best score.  The new probabilities for each hole are shown in Table 2.

Table 2
Probability of Scoring Relative to Par on Each Hole after Two Rounds


Handicap
Score Relative to Par
-1
0
+1
+2
Low Handicap
.19
.80
.01
.00
High Handicap
.00
.36
.60
.04

The low handicap player would average 3.24 strokes under par while the high handicap player would average 12.24 strokes over par.  The difference between players is now 15.48 strokes.  To make the competition fair, the handicaps should be multiplied by a factor of .86 (i.e., 15.48/18).

For a four-ball eclectic the percentage allowance should be even lower.  Assume that both players get an identical partner for a four-ball eclectic.  The probabilities of each score after two rounds for both teams are shown in Table 3.

Table 3
Probability of Scoring Relative to Par on Each Hole after Two Rounds of Four-Ball


Handicap
Score Relative to Par
-1
0
+1
+2
Low Handicap Team
.3439
.6560
.0001
.0000
High Handicap Team
.0000
.5904
.4080
.0016

The low handicap team would average 6.19 strokes under par and the high handicap team would average 7.37 strokes over par.  The difference in team scores would be 13.56 strokes.  To make the competition fair for four-ball, the allowance should be 75 percent (i.e., 13.56/18).

The allowances of 86 percent for a stroke play eclectic and 75 percent for a four-ball eclectic were derived using a very simple model.  To see if these allowances are reasonable, a small four-ball eclectic tournament is analyzed.  The allowance for each player in the competition was 90 percent of his handicap.  The tournament handicaps and results from the first and second day for two flights are presented in the Appendix.
In a perfectly equitable competition, scores should not be correlated with handicaps.  When Day 1 Scores were regressed against Total Handicap, the estimated equations were:

Flight 1                  Day 1 Score = 64.7 - .004·Total Handicap
Flight 2                  Day 1 Score = 72.1 - .250·Total Handicap

In Flight 1, the coefficient of Total Handicap variable was both small and not statistically significant
(t-statistic = -.01).  This finding implies taking 90 percent of each player’s handicap led to a fair competition.  A one-day four-ball competition is similar to a two-day stroke play eclectic.  Basically, one best score out of two is chosen.  So the theoretical allowance of 86 percent is clearly in the ball park.  In Flight 2, both the coefficient of the Total Handicap variable and its t-statistic (t=-.9) were larger.  While the coefficient is not statistically significant at the 95 percent level of confidence, it does indicate equity could be improved if the allowance was less than 90 percent.
   
The second day results were:

Flight 1                  Day 2 Score = 60.8 - .086·Total Handicap (t-statistic = -.59)
Flight 2                  Day 2 Score = 67.1 - .257·Total Handicap (t=statistic = -1.30)

The equations indicate the higher handicap teams are favored, but neither coefficient is significant at the 95 percent level of confidence.  The equation for Flight 1 predicts the highest handicap team should have a score 1.3 strokes lower that the lowest handicap team (i.e., the difference in team handicaps multiplied by .086).   If the 75 percent allowance was used, the high handicap team would lose three more strokes than the low handicap team.  On average, this should lead to a reduction in the highest handicap team’s score of 1.5 strokes.  In essence, the advantage of the high handicap team is wiped out when the 75 percent allowance is used.  In Flight 2, the regression equation predicts a 2.5 stroke advantage for the highest handicap team.   Using the 75 percent allowance would reduce the score of the highest handicap team by 1.7 strokes on average.  While the highest handicap team would still have an advantage, it would be less than one stroke.

Of the top three finishers in each flight, only one came from the top half (i.e., the lower handicap teams) the flight.   Clearly, 90 percent did not produce an equitable competition.  The lesson here is Tournament Committees should study the effect of allowances on tournament outcomes.  Experiments with different allowances should proceed until equitable competition is achieved.  
   
Appendix
Flight Scores and Handicaps
Tournament Results-Flight 1

Team
Total Handicap
Day 1
Day 2
1
11
67
62
2
12
60
57
3
16
67
60
4
21
64
59
5
21
69
63
6
23
63
56
7
24
68
59
8
24
62
58
9
25
62
57
10
26
65
60

Tournament Results-Flight 2

Team
Total Handicap
Day 1
Day 2
1
26
62
59
2
26
65
61
3
28
67
60
4
29
66
58
5
30
69
63
6
30
63
60
7
34
61
56
8
33
65
57
9
35
66
61
10
36
60
57




[1] The USGA’s “bonus for excellence” and possible differences in scoring variances would have small effects on the handicaps.  The effects, however, are small and are neglected in this analysis.

Monday, May 4, 2015

Predicting the Overall Winner of a Golf Tournament When Players Compete in Flights

Here is a probability problem that arose during a recent golf tournament.  The field of 36 two-man teams was divided into six flights.  The lower-handicap players were assigned to the first three flights and played from the blue tees.  The higher-handicap players were assigned to the last three flights and played from the white tees.  The blue tees had a Course Rating one stroke higher than the white tees.
 
The competition was conducted over two rounds.  The first round was four-ball and the second round was Pinehurst.  The competition was conducted at full handicap for all players using Stableford scoring.   That is, there was no 90 percent reduction in handicap for the four-ball competition nor were handicaps adjusted for the difference in Course Ratings in accordance with Section 3-5 of the USGA Handicap System.  Given these conditions of the competition, what is the probability the overall winner (i.e., the highest Stableford point total) would come from a blue tee flight?

To make this problem analytically tractable, it is assumed all of the blue tee players are ten handicaps and all of the white tee players are twenty handicaps.  If the USGA recommendation for four-ball was used, the blue tee players would have their handicaps reduced to nine (i.e., 90 percent of their Course Handicap).  Similarly, the white tee players would have their handicaps reduced to eighteen.  The blue tee players would have their handicaps increased by one-stroke (the difference in Course Ratings between tees).   That would bring the blue tee players back to ten handicaps.  The white tee players would be eighteen handicaps under USGA guidelines, but under the conditions of the competition they are allowed two extra strokes and play as twenty handicaps.
 
The two extra handicap strokes should lead to a 2-point increase in the Stableford score of the white tee teams in the four-ball competition.   On the first and second stroke allocation holes, the white tee players would get an additional handicap stroke.  Unless both players had a quadruple bogey on these holes, the additional strokes would lead to additional Stableford points.[1]

In the Pinehurst Competition, the teams from the blue tees should have received an additional handicap stroke under Section 3-5 of the USGA Handicap System.   Since these teams did not receive the Section 3-5 adjustment, their Stableford score will be one Stableford point lower—unless the team scored a triple bogey on the eleventh stroke allocation hole.

The next assumption is that if the USGA recommendations were followed, the average team score in each flight would be equal.   Without the adjustments, the white tee flight should have an average Stableford point total three points higher than the blue tee flight (2 points in four-ball and 1 point in the Pinehurst competition). 

The probability of a blue tee team winning depends upon the distribution of scores within each group.  The wider the distribution, the better chance a blue tee team has of overcoming the three point difference in average scores.  For this analysis, it is assumed the standard deviation of team scores is three points for both flights.  That is, approximately two-thirds of the team scores are within plus or minus three points of the average. The probabilities of scores can be estimated using the standard normal distribution table as shown below in Table 1.[2]
Table 1
Probability of Team Scores

Average
+1
+2
+3
+4
+5
+6
+7
.135
.1240
.1052
.0823
.0542
.0332
.0186
.0150

For a blue tee team to be the over-all winner, one of the combinations of outcomes shown in Table 2 must occur.  (Note:  Ties between a blue tee team and a white tee team are not considered a win for the blue tee team.)
Table 2
Winning Combinations for a Blue Tee Team to be the Overall Winner

Blue Tee
 Outcome

Probability
White Tee Outcome

Probability
Probability of Both Outcomes
+7
.238
No Team > +3
.098
.023
≥+6
.459
No Team > +2
.017
.006
≥+5
.712
No Team > +1
.001
.001

The probabilities of each outcome will depend upon the number of players in each flight.  The tournament in question had 18 teams in each flight so that number will be used.  The probability of at least one Blue Tee scores +7 is one minus the probability that there are no +7 team scores ((1- (1 - 0.015)18 = .238).  The probabilities of at least one blue tee team scores +6 or greater or +5 or greater are calculated similarly.

For a blue team scoring +7 to win outright, no white tee team can score higher than +3.  The probability of a no white tee team scoring  greater than +3  is the probability of a team scoring +3 or less raised to the eighteenth power (i.e., (1-(.0542 +.0186 + .0150))18 which equals .098.  Similarly, the probability of all white tee teams scoring +2 or less is .017 and the probability all teams scoring +1 or less is .001.

The probability of a blue team winning with a +7 is the probability of it scoring +7 times the probability no white tee team scoring +3 or greater.  That probability is .023 as shown in Table 2.  The probability of a blue tee team being the overall winner is the sum of probabilities for the three ways it can win shown in Table 2.  That probability is .03.  In other words, a blue tee team should be expected to win once in every 33 years.

Whether the format of this competition is strongly discriminatory against blue tee players rests upon the validity of the assumptions.  Is there a three point difference in average scores between blue tee and white tee teams?  Is the standard deviation for both tees equal to 3.0 points?  Is there a large difference in Course Handicaps between blue and white tee players?  How often are blue tee teams the over-all winner?  A check of tournament statistics can determine if these assumptions are realistic and if the blue tee teams are at the disadvantage claimed here.
 


[1] If the partnership had different handicaps (i.e., were not both twenty handicaps), the two stroke advantage could lead to an increase in their Stableford score of between zero and four points.  See Dougharty, Laurence, The Four-Ball Adjustment Under Section 3-5, www.ongolfhandicaps.com, September 15, 2014.
[2] For example, the probability of a team scoring +2 is the area under the standard normal curve from 1.5/3 to 2.5/3.  This would be .3085 - .2033 = .1052. 

Thursday, April 16, 2015

The Case for Eliminating Decision 3-5/2 from the USGA Handicap System

Decision 3-5/2 of the USGA Handicap System 2012-2015 states a competition that does not adjust handicaps in accordance with Section 3-5 waives a Rule of Golf.   It is not clear which rule is being waived.  Nor is it clear any penalty would be assessed for conducting a competition that did not follow Section 3-5.  A rule without sanctions is not a rule, but general guidance.  The case for changing or eliminating Decision 3-5/2 is made below. 

Here is how the decision reads presently at www.usga.org:

3-5/2 – Golf Club Chooses Not to Follow Section 3-5 of the USGA Handicap System
Q:  May golf clubs choose not to follow Section 3-5 of "The USGA Handicap System" manual if the club's groups are competing from different tees?

A:  No. Not applying Section 3-5 of The "USGA Handicap System" when players are competing from different tees would be waiving a Rule of Golf, and the Committee in charge of a competition does not have the authority to waive a Rule of Golf.

Note, the USGA no longer states which Rule of Golf is waived when Section 3-5 is not followed.  In the printed edition of the Handicap System, the reader was referred to “Rules of Golf,” Decision 6-2/1.  That decision is shown below:

6-2/1 Meaning of "Handicap"
Q. Under a handicapping system where the player has to adjust his handicap in accordance with the rating for the course he is playing, a player's handicap before adjustment is 4.8. After applying the appropriate adjustment for the course and the tees to be used for that competition, the player's handicap is 6. Which is his "handicap" for the purposes of Rule 6-2?
A. 6. In a stroke-play competition the player must ensure that the handicap for the course that he is to play and the tees to be used is recorded on his score card when it is returned to the Committee.

First, how does a player have a 4.8 handicap?  Handicaps are integers.[1]  It is probable the USGA meant a player had an Index of 4.8 and not a handicap of 4.8.  The probable intent of this decision was to ensure the player calculated his handicap correctly based on the Slope Rating of the course to be played—i.e., the player could not meet the requirement of Rule 6-2 by recording his correct Index, but an incorrect Course Handicap.  Second, how does ignoring Section 3-5 violate this rule?   If a player does not record his handicap on his scorecard or reports a handicap higher than to which he is entitled, he is disqualified under Rule 6-2.  But if the players from the tees with the higher course rating fail to add additional strokes to their handicap, there would not be a violation of Rule 6-2.  More importantly, it does not appear to be the player’s responsibility to make the Section 3-5 adjustment.  That is the duty of the Committee as inferred from Decision 6-2b/0.5 of the Rules of Golf:

6-2b/0.5 Meaning of "Handicap" When Full Handicap Not Used

Q.  It is the condition of a stroke-play competition (e.g., four-ball) that players will not receive their full handicap allowances. Under Rule 6-2b, what is the player responsible for recording on his score card?
A.  He must record his full handicap. It is the Committee's responsibility to apply the condition of competition to adjust his handicap.

Since the Committee assigned the tournament handicaps with no Section 3-5 adjustment, no players are at fault and no penalty can be assigned.

Scott Hovde of the USGA attempted to defend Decision 3-5/2 when he wrote:[2]

“The key here is that if a competition is played under the Rules of Golf, the committee cannot waive a Rule of Golf (they do have the option to not play under the Rules of Golf).  There are no specific penalty strokes assessed when a committee decides to waive a Rule of Golf…no different than if they told competitors to play OB as a lateral hazard or allow for grounding clubs in a hazard.  It is when the players are then forced to not play by the Rules of Golf (in this case, potentially an incorrect handicap, which may result in a DQ per Decision 6-2b/3.5) that is the issue.  Basically the committee (club) is knowingly putting players in a position that, if playing by the Rules of Golf, would be in conflict with the Rules of Golf.”

Hovde is arguing that 1) a Committee states no Sec. 3-5 adjustment will be made, 2) the player enters his handicap accordingly, and 3) the Committee disqualifies the player for following the Committee’s instructions.  This would be both bizarre and highly unlikely.    

The USGA took a different path when it was asked if a match at full handicap was equitable (See Decision 9-4a/1 of The USGA Handicap System).  The answer was no.  Decision 3-5/2 should reflect the same reasoning (i.e., comment on the equity and not the legality of ignoring Section 3-5) or better yet be eliminated.[3]  

Decision 3-5/2 was added in 2006.  That means ignoring Section 3-5 before 2006 was not waiving a Rule of Golf.  I suspect nothing in the Rules of Golf was changed in 2006 that necessitated Decision 3/5-2.  More probably, an advocate of Section 3-5 pushed for the current language in an attempt to promote wider acceptance of the adjustment.  But as Dean Knuth wrote, Rules of Golf should not be used as a hammer within the Handicap System.[4]  The USGA should educate and not mandate Committees on how to run an equitable tournament—i.e., when Sec. 3-5 should be employed and when it should be avoided.  Moreover, since compliance to Section 3-5 is close to universal, Decision 3-5/2 serves no useful purpose and could be eliminated without consequence.



[1] The CONGU Unified Handicapping System does have an “Exact Handicap” which is expressed to the nearest tenth.  A player in the CONGU System, however, does not adjust his handicap in accordance with the rating for the course and is therefore unaffected by Decision 6-2/1.
[2] E-mail to author, April 8, 2015.
[3] Section 9-4 of the Handicap System does say players must (emphasis added) apply the difference in USGA Course Ratings from the tees played.”   It would be more consistent with the rest of Section 9-4 to say players should apply the difference.  The USGA overuses the term “must.” Section 3-5 states the adjustment must be added to the higher-rated tee players’ Course Handicap. Later in the Section 3 Decisions, it is stated the Committee could subtract the adjustment from the handicaps of the players competing from the lower-rated set of tees.  The use of “must” implies necessity which is lacking in this case.
[4] Letter to the USGA from Dean Knuth, former director of Handicapping at the USGA, January 18, 2001 as presented at www.popeofslope.com.