Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Why You Win (or Lose) at Skins


Introduction – “Skins” is a very popular golf game.  The game is simple in concept.  A group of players play a hole and if one player makes the lowest score, he wins a skin.  At the end of the round, a pool of money is divided among the players who won skin(s).  The popularity of the game derives in part from the ability of a player to win a skin even if he isn’t playing well. Skins, however, is not like a lottery where everyone has an equal chance to win.  A player’s success will depend upon 1) the Skins method (i.e., how skins are determined), 2) the distribution of handicaps among the competitors, and 3) the cap on the maximum handicap allowed.  Each of these factors is discussed in turn.
Skins Method – There are seven commonly used methods for playing skins:
1. Gross Skins – A skin is awarded only if one player has the lowest gross score on a hole.  The value of a skin is equal to the betting pool divided by the number of skins.
2. Net Skins – A skin is awarded only if one player has the lowest net score on a hole.[1]    The value of a skin is equal to the betting pool divided by the number of skins.
3. Net Skins Played at ½ Handicap – This is the same as Method 2 except the player only receives one-half of his handicap.  If this results in a player having a “n +1/2” handicap, the player deducts a one-half of a stroke on the hole with a n+1 stroke allocation.  For example, a player with a handicap of 7 ½ , would get ½ stroke on the 8th handicap allocation hole. The value of a skin is equal to the betting pool divided by the number of skins.
4. Separate Gross and Net Skins – Gross and net skins are determined at full handicap.  The value of a gross skin is equal to half the betting pool divided by the number of gross skins.  The value of a net skin is equal to half the betting pool divided by the number of net skins.
5. Equal Gross and Net Skins – Gross and net Skins are determined at full handicap. The value of any skin is equal to the betting pool divided by the total number of skins.
6. No Double Win – This is the same as Method 5 with one exception.  A player cannot win a gross and net skin on the same hole. 
7. Net Skins, but Gross Skin Takes Precedence – If a player has a gross skin on a hole, he is awarded a “net skin” even if other players had net scores equal to the player’s gross score.  In essence some net scores are better than others.  On closer inspection, this method is identical to Method 6 as long as a player cannot receive more than one handicap stroke on a hole.[2]  Therefore, this method is eliminated from the analysis.
To examine the equity of each method a simulation model was built.  The probabilities of a 5, 10, and 15 handicap player were estimated (see Appendix).  In the first analysis, it was assumed that 5 players of each handicap level were competing. The expected return (the amount returned per dollar bet) for each group is shown in Table 1 below.
Table 1
Expected Return per Dollar Bet

Method
5-Handicap
10-Handicap
15-Handicap
1. Gross Skins
$1.50
$.97
$.53
2. Net Skins
$.77
$1.04
$1.19
3. ½ Handicap
$1.18
$.89
$.93
4. Separate Gross and Net
$1.14
$1.00
$.86
5. Equal Gross and Net
$1.13
$1.00
$.87
6. No Double Win
$1.19
$.92
$.89

The lower-handicap player has a distinct advantage in all methods except Method 2 (Net Skins).  Methods 3, 4, 5 and 6 are essentially equivalent in terms of equity. 

Handicap Distribution – The previous analysis had an equal number of players in each handicap group.  A player’s chances are improved if the field does not include many players with handicaps similar to his.  To demonstrate this effect, estimates of the expected return are made when there is 1 player at a handicap level and 7 players in each of the other levels.  Table 2 presents the expected return when there is only one player at the designated handicap level.

Table 2
Expected Return with Only One Player at the Designated Handicap Level

Method
5-Handicap
10-Handicap
15-Handicap
1. Gross Skins
$1.97
$1.02
$.40
2. Net Skins
$.98
$1.34
$1.57
3. ½ Handicap
$1.47
$.1.06
$1.3
4. Separate Gross and Net
$1.48
$1.18
$.99
5 Equal Gross and Net
$1.49
$1.17
$1.03
6. No Double Win
$2.19
$1.11
$1.24

Under Method 6, for example, if there is only one 5-handicap player (instead of five) the player’s expected return jumps from $1.19 to $2.19.  This is due to the player’s birdies being more likely to win a skin when he doesn’t face competition from other 5-handicap players.

Cap on Maximum Handicap – In some skins games, the maximum handicap allowed is 18 or one handicap stroke per hole.  To examine the equity of this cap on handicaps, five additional players with 25-handicaps were added to the simulation model. The expected returns for each handicap level are shown in Table 3.

Table 3
Expected Return per Dollar Bet

Method
5-Handicap
10-Handicap
15-Handicap
25-Handicap
1. Gross Skins
$2.02
$1.22
$.68
$.09
2. Net Skins
$.64
$.97
$1.29
$1.10
3. ½ Handicap
$1.34
$.99
$1.10
$.57
4. Separate Gross and Net
$1.33
$1.09
$.98
$.59
5 Equal Gross and Net
$1.36
$1.08
$.97
$.59
6. No Double Win
$1.41
$1.00
$.92
$.67

As can be seen, the expected returns for 5-, 10-, and 15-handicap players have been increased with the addition of the five 25-handicap players.  The 25-handicap player does not do well under most scenarios.  It should be noted, however, that not all 25-handicaps are alike.  A 25-handicap who has a large variance in his hole scores (i.e. he has more pars and more triple bogeys than assumed in the model) will do better than Table 3 suggests.  Under reasonable assumptions about the hole-score variance of a 25-handicap player, however, it is unlikely this player will do as well as the 5-handicap player.   
 
Method 5, No Double Win, is usually defended in terms of equity.  “A player should not get two skins for one hole,” it is argued.  Double skins, however, are most likely to go to the medium handicap player.  The elimination of double skins gives an even greater edge to the low-handicap player.  This is demonstrated in Table 4 which shows the total number of skins by handicap for the two methods.

Table 4
Total Skins by Handicap (1,000 trials)

Method
5-Handicap
10-Handicap
15-Handicap
25-Handicap
5. Equal Gross and Net
4372
3500
3112
1855
6. No Double Win
3563
2502
2332
1698
 
 
 
 
 
Percent Reduction in Skins
18.5%
28.5%
25.1%
8.5%

The “No Double Win” provision eliminates a larger percentage of skins for the 10- and 15-handicap groups than it does for the 5- and 25-handicap group.  Method 6 basically shifts money to handicap groups at the extreme ends from the handicap groups in the middle. Whether this is more equitable depends upon the eye of the beholder.

Conclusion – Skins is golf’s mini-version of Powerball.  The odds are stacked against most players, but it is still fun to play.  Played for nominal stakes, a player should not be too concerned about his expected losses.  If a few low-handicappers are turning the weekly skins game into an annuity, however, a player should consider switching his contribution to a tax deductible charity.                                         

Appendix

Score to Par
5-Handicap
10-Handicap
15-Handicap
25-Handicap
-2
.005
.003
.000
.000
-1
.140
.090
.060
.010
0
.450
.350
.250
.150
+1
.310
.380
.430
.380
+2
.070
.140
.200
.300
+3
.020
.030
.040
.100
+4
.005
.007
.020
.060

 



[1] If a player has a handicap less than or equal to 18, his  gross score on a hole is reduced by one stroke to obtain his net score if his handicap is less than or equal to the stroke allocation for that hole. Otherwise, his net score is equal to his gross score.
[2] Under Method 7, if a player has a gross skin, he receives a “net skin” since a gross skin takes precedence. All net skins are awarded a “net skin” unless the player also had a gross skin on that hole.  In essence, Method 7 is Method 6—gross and net skins, but a player cannot win both on a hole.

Friday, May 31, 2013

Bureaucracy, Anchoring, and Adam Scott


 The United State Golf Association (USGA) recently released a forty page explanation of its decision to adopt Rule 14-1b that makes anchoring illegal.[1] The explanation could have been considerably shorter.  To wit:

The USGA looks upon the long putter in the same way Judge Smails views Al Czervik in Caddyshack.  Though we believe the long putter should be banned, a previous USGA Committee ruled it legal.  Rather than start a food fight with our former colleagues, we have ruled “anchoring,” the most pervasive stroke using the long putter, illegal.  It is our hope that this ruling will diminish the usefulness of the long putter and in the end lead to its demise.

The USGA goes to great lengths to argue “that freely swinging the entire club is integral to maintaining the traditions of the game and preserving golf as an enjoyable game of skill and challenge”[2]and therefore, Rule-14-1b is necessary to protect the integrity of the game.  It’s more likely the USGA is trying to protect its image of the game.  The Nabobs of New Jersey see a player using a long putter holding the U.S. Open trophy as a portent of societal decay.  Unless it acts, the next thing you’ll see is “some stuck-up jockey boy sittin’ on top of Dan Patch.” 

The USGA has acted before to protect the manly image of the game.  When Sam Snead started to putt croquet style, setting golf on par with an English lawn party, the USGA was quick to make the style illegal.  Adam Scott is the modern day Snead.  Scott’s golf swing is characterized by grace and power.  He walks the fairways with movie star looks and Aussie charm.  He is every man’s son and every woman’s heartthrob. Scott is the perfect image golf would like to project…until he gets to the green.  There he takes on the persona of Maude Frickert sweeping off the front porch.  If he only putted like Mr. Jones or Mr. Hogan, then all would be right.  Rule 14-1b is adopted to take care of that.

Much of the USGA’s explanation is muddled for the purpose of drawing attention away the Rule’s real objective.  First, the USGA argues the Rules of Golf are not established on the benefits of a (putting) method that might or might not be allowed.[3] Second, they argue anchored methods of stroke clearly provide a player with a potential advantage.[4] (If the Rules are not based on benefits, why devote a section to the potential advantages of anchored putting?)  Third, the USGA argues empirical evidence is irrelevant because ”the Rules of Golf…rest on considerations such as tradition, experience and judgment, not on science and statistics.”[5]  In essence, the USGA argues benefit is irrelevant, then implies it is another reason for 14-1b, and finally argues that this benefit cannot be measured but only assessed by the combined wisdom of the USGA Rules Committee.

If science and statistics are to be banned in rule making, doesn’t this argue for closing the USGA Test Center?  After all, can’t the initial velocity and spin of the ball be measured by human judgment?   The ban on square grooves in 2007, which is an action very similar in form to the ban on anchoring, was the subject of intense empirical analysis.  Interestingly, there is no mention of the square grooves controversy in the USGAS’s lengthy report.

But the Luddites at the USGA aren’t content with arguing science is irrelevant. They mistakenly argue there is not sufficient evidence for an empirical analysis.  The USGA contends that ShotLink (a system used on the PGA tour) measures the success of putting, but does not measure inherent ability, recent or current injury or physical conditions, current form, extent of practice, effect of conditions, and countless other factors that may affect a player’s performance.  The USGA does not realize that all empirical analyses, by necessity, omit variables. This does not mean analysis cannot be a valid predictor of performance. For example, assume you have a cross-sectional study of school performance.  The explanatory variables are school spending, socio-economic status, and so forth.  You do not have data on whether a student felt well on test day or if he tends to choke on tests.  The study assumes such missing variables are not correlated with the explanatory variables (i.e., they are part of the random error).  The study would still be capable of making an estimate of the impact of school spending on student performance, and provide a probability that the impact is greater than zero (i.e., the significance test for the coefficient of the school spending variable). The same would be true in a study of the effectiveness of anchoring. 

The USGA also does not seem to understand the ShotLink system.  It argues the ShotLink data are used to produce a putting statistic known as “strokes gained-putting,” as well as a number of statistics which are intended to assess…the comparative success of Tour players.  The ShotLink data base actually consists of millions of putts.  Pope and Schweitzer made use of this data base in trying to determine if players were more successful at par putts than birdie putts.[6] Pope and Schweitzer employed many of the control variables the USGA appears to insist on.  They used player fixed effects that consist of various measures of a player’s ability.  They also included variables measuring the position of the putt on the green, distance from the hole, and the player’s position in the tournament to name just a few. It would be a simple matter to introduce a dummy variable representing whether a player anchored or did not anchor his putter.  The estimated coefficient of that dummy variable would be an estimate of the size of any advantage of disadvantage of using an anchored putter.

The USGA also contends that if statistical analysis showed anchoring was not an advantage, it could be due to a biased sample.[7]  Many who have gone to the long putter are simply not good putters, and it is not fair to compare them with a group that contains Tiger Woods, et. al.  Using ShotLink data, however, it would be possible to examine how the elite players using the anchoring method do on short putts under pressure (i.e., when they are in contention on Sunday) and compare their success rate with elite players who do not anchor. 

The USGA’s reluctance to undertake scientific inquiry stems from the probable outcome of such research. Since players using the anchored method do not rate highly in the putting statistic the PGA Tour keeps--Strokes Gained Putting—it is unlikely more formal analysis would find the advantage for anchored putting the USGA claims.[8]

In summary, it is our belief—based on “experience and judgment”—Rule 14-1b will not do anything to level the playing field since the playing field is already level.  It will obtain its real objective, however, of moving golf up on the perceived scale of athleticism, edging it slightly ahead of curling--except in Canada. 


    



[1] United States Golf Association, Explanation of Decision to Adopt Rule 14-1b of the Rules of Golf, Far Hills, NJ, May 21, 2013.
[2] Ibid, p. 8.
[3] Ibid., p. 6.
[4] Ibid, p. 10.
[5] Ibid., p. 13.
[6] Pope Devin. G and Schweitzer, Maurice E., Is Tiger Woods Loss Averse? Persistent Bias in the Face of Experience, Competition, and High Stakes, American Economic Review (February 2011, pp. 129-157
[7] USGA, op. cit., p. 14.
[8] As of May 26, 2013, Keegan Bradley was ranked 37th , Webb Simpson was ranked 44th ,  and Tim Clark was ranked 54th in Strokes Gained-Putting.