Monday, February 4, 2013

The Mathematical Underpinnings of the "New" Slope Rating




To see  how the “new” Slope Rating is related to the USGA’s Slope Rating, it is necessary to review the origins of the USGA’s Slope System.  The theory behind the Slope System was first put forward by R.C. Stroud and L.J. Riccio in an article entitled Mathematical underpinning so the slope handicap system.[1]  Stroud starts with Figure 1 below that purports to show how the average unadjusted differential of players from Perfect Valley vary by course.[2]

                       

Perfect Valley is depicted as a course of moderate difficulty.  Stroud assigns Perfect Valley a slope of 1.13.    The slope of 1.13 is due to three factors embedded in the handicap system: 1) using only the best 10 of the last 20 differentials, 2) Equitable stroke control, and 3) the .96 bonus for excellence factor. This gives the illusion that an average course would have a Slope Rating of 1.13.  This would not be correct.  Whatever course Stroud selected as his reference course would have a Slope Rating of 1.13.  For example, assume Stroud picked Panther Mountain as his reference course.  The slope of the line relating Average Differential and Panther Mountain Handicap would still be 1.13.  The slope relating the Average Score at Perfect Valley with Panther Mountain Handicap would be 0.92  (i.e., 1.13x1.13/1.39) and the slope at Open Flats would be 0.74.[3]

What should a player’s Standard Course Handicap (i.e., Perfect Valley Handicap or what the USGA now terms a player’s "Index") be at other courses?[4] For generality, let us name the course in question “Any Course.”  The handicap formula tells us:

1)    Standard Handicap(Any Course) = ATBD(Any Course) x .96
Where,
ATBD(Any Course) = Average of Ten Best Differentials at Any Course                                  
The player’s Course Handicap at Any Course can be written as,

2)    Course Handicap(Any Course) = ATBD(Any Course)/1.13

The ATBD(Any Course) is related to his Standard Handicap by eq. 3,

3)    ATBD(Any Course) x .96 = Slope Rating(Any Course) x Standard Handicap
Where,
Slope Rating(Any Course) = Slope of the line relating average differentials at Any  Course with Standard Course handicaps
Substituting eq. 3 into eq. 2, the Handicap(Any Course) becomes

4)    Handicap(Any Course) = Slope Rating(Any Course) x Standard Handicap/1.13
In summary, a player’s handicap at Any Course is given by the product of his Standard Course Handicap and Slope Rating(Any Course) divided by 1.13.

The Slope Rating, however, has little intuitive meaning.  A more informative measure of a course is what is termed the “new” Slope Rating. The new Slope Rating is simply the percentage of your Standard Handicap that is allowed at a course.  In essence,

5)    Handicap(Any Course) = New Slope Rating(Any Course) x Standard Handicap
Substituting from eq. 4 into eq. 5, the New Slope Rating can be defined as:

6)    New Slope Rating(Any Course) = Slope Rating(Any Course)/1.13
If the New Slope Rating of a course is 120, for example, a player gets to play at 120 percent of his Standard Handicap.[5] 









[1] Stroud, R.C., Riccio, L.J., “Mathematical underpinnings of the slope handicap system,” Science and Golf, E & F Spon, London, 1990, p. 136.
[2] Stroud actually plots average score versus handicap in his paper.  But he also claims (op.cit., p. 140):
So the better half of average differentials (ATBD) divided by average score (for any handicap level) is 1.04/1.13 = 0.92. 
This is not correct.  A ten-handicap, for example, would have an ATBD of 10.4 (ATBD= Handicap/.96).  His average score would be the Course Rating plus 11.3 (Handicap x 1.13).   If the Course Rating was 72.0, the ratio of ATBD to average score would be 10.4/83.3 = 0.12.  What Stroud probably meant was that the ratio of ATBD to Average Differential (Average Score – Course Rating) is 0.92.  Therefore, his figure has been changed to reflect this correction. The figure also assumes the average differential of a scratch player is zero.  This assumption is not correct, but is built into the Slope Handicap System.
[3] The myth that 113 is the Slope Rating of an average course was probably started by Dean Knuth, former Director of Handicapping for the USGA, when he wrote:
“The slope of the scores line of an average course has been observed to be 1.13 and USGA Slope Rating is referenced as 113 to deal with whole numbers.” (See Knuth D., “A two parameter golf course rating system,” Science and Golf, E & F Spon, London, 1990, p. 143.)
 Knuth’s explanation is either wrong or possibly just not stated with precision.  The Slope Rating is the slope of the regression line of total score versus USGA handicap for players from the reference course (named Perfect Valley in USGA research papers).  The slope of the regression line of score versus handicap for players at their home course will be 1.13 for all courses according to the USGA. 
[4] The handicap of a player at the Standard Course is measured in tenths and is identical to what is now termed a player’s “index.” See “Simplifying the Slope Handicap System,” www.ongolfhandicaps, 2/1/2013.
[5] The new Slope Rating has the same validity problems as the old Slope Rating.  Both the USGA’s old Slope Rating and the New Slope Rating are based on the same two assumptions: 1) There is linear relationship between average differentials at Any Course and the handicaps at the Standard Course, and 2) Average differentials are 1.13 times a player’s handicaps.  The validity of these assumptions has not been tested in the peer reviewed literature.











Friday, February 1, 2013

Simplifying the Slope Handicap System



The Slope Handicap System has been in place for approximately 30 years.  The number of golfers who actually understand what a Slope Rating means, however, is still quite small.  The confusion and misunderstanding surrounding the Slope Rating is not difficult to believe given its obtuse definition:
Slope Rating – The slope of the line plotting a player’s average differential at a course versus his handicap at the reference course.
To make the system less mysterious and simpler, two changes are suggested. First, rename a player’s “index” and make it his “Standard Handicap” (measured to the nearest tenth).  The USGA’s “index” is really not an index as commonly defined.  Introducing this non-golf term into the lexicon of handicapping only added another layer of obfuscation.
Second, change the definition of the Slope Rating to the old Slope Rating divided by 113.  (Note: The term "Slope Rating" is kept to minimize confusion.)  The new Slope Rating is the percentage of a player’s Standard Handicap that is allowed at a particular course. To demonstrate the simplicity of the revised system, assume a player has a 10.0 Standard Handicap.  When he plays a course with a new Slope Rating of 120, he is allowed 120 percent of his Standard Handicap and his Course Handicap is 12. In essence, the Slope Rating can be viewed intuitively as the "slope" of a hill.  The steeper the hill, the more handicap a player needs to reach his goal (i.e., have a net score equal to the Course Rating).

Here are the advantages of the proposed changes:
1. It has intuitive appeal and is easily understood. If you are going to a course with a New Slope Rating of 120, you know your Standard Handicap will be increased by 20 percent.  If you are going to a course with an Old Slope Rating of 136 (which is the same as a New Slope Rating of 120), both your ultimate Course Handicap and its meaning are less clear.
 2. If the New Slope Rating is implemented, the ubiquitous number “113” will be hidden from view.   A Slope Rating of 113 has been represented as the Slope Rating of a course of average difficulty.  That is not necessarily correct.  If the USGA had chosen Pine Valley for its reference course, the Slope Rating at Pine Valley would have been 113.  The “113” stems from the USGA’s assertion that at any course, a player’s average differential will be 1.13 times his handicap.  In other words, “113” represents the bias in the Handicap System that favors the lower handicap player.   It is not prudent to remind the knowledgeable player of this inequity every time he computes his handicap.  The reference course would now have a Slope Rating of 100.  Since the Slope Rating is an "index," its reference standard should be 100 and not 113.
3. The changes would simplify answering the question, “What is your handicap?"  Under the present system, if your answer is "My USGA Index is 11.2," you will get a lot of quizzical looks if the questioner is a non-golfer. You could patiently explain that a golfer has a myriad of handicaps depending upon the Slope Rating of the course.  By the time you are finished with your explanation, the questioner will have excused himself and moved on to someone more interesting.  It would be so much easier to say my Standard Handicap is 11 (or 11.2 if you want to add some spurious accuracy your audience cares little about).

It is unclear why the USGA chose to describe courses by what it measures (i.e., the Slope Rating) rather that by what golfers can easily use and understand (i.e., the new Slope Rating).  Because of that choice, golfers have suffered and will continue to suffer needless confusion.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

The USGA’s “Bonus for Excellence” Ruse


 
The United States Golf Association (USGA) states the “bonus for excellence is an incentive for players to improve their game that is built into the USGA Handicap System.  It is the term used to describe the small percentage below perfect equity (emphasis added) that is used to calculate a Handicap Index.”[1]  The bonus for excellence (BFE) is currently set at .96.

Dean Knuth, former Senior Director of Handicapping for the USGA, described another purpose of the BFE when he wrote in Golf Digest:

 “Historically, the USGA wanted to reward the accomplishments of better players…For a six-stroke difference in handicaps the better player gains a one-shot advantage (due to the BFE) and should win 60 percent of the matches.”[2]

The argument of this paper is that the BFE is neither an effective incentive to improve nor a reward for superior performance and should be eliminated from the USGA Handicap System. 

To demonstrate the ineffectiveness of the BFE, we examine matches between a scratch player and players of various ability.  As a measure of ability we use the average of a player’s ten best differentials (ATBD).  Table 1 presents the perfect equity handicap(PE), as defined by the USGA, and the handicap using the BFE(BE) for players with ATBDs varying from 35.0 to 0.0.  If a player’s ATBD is 35.0 (Slope Rating = 113), the BFE reduces his handicap by one-stroke. This is termed the Bonus for Excellence Penalty shown in column 4 of Table 1.   Assume the player improves to the point where his ATBD is 15.0.  The BFE reduces this player’s handicap by one-stroke. In essence, even though he has improved dramatically, he is no better off in his match against a scratch player.  In both cases, he is getting one less stroke than the USGA considers perfect equity.

Table 1

Bonus for Excellence Penalty (Slope Rating = 113)

 

Avg. of 10 Best Differentials(ATBD)
Perfect Equity Handicap(PE)
Bonus for Excellence Handicap(BE)
Bonus for Excellence Penalty
35.0
35
34
-1
30.0
30
29
-1
25.0
25
24
-1
20.0
20
19
-1
15.0
15
14
-1
12.0
12
12
0
10.0
10
10
0
5.0
5
5
0
0.0
0
0
0

 

Table 1 also shows improvement does not improve his competitive position among his fellow high-handicappers.  The difference between the PE and BE is the same for all players with ATBDs between 35.0 and 13.0—i.e., approximately 59 percent of players with a USGA index.[3]

Table 1 also reveals that Knuth’s assertion that the BFE provides the better player with a one-shot advantage when handicaps differ by 6-strokes is in error.  Without the BFE, a 35-handicap would receive 20 strokes from a 15-handicap player.  This is the same number of strokes he receives when the BFE is applied.  Knuth would be roughly correct under the old system when the BFE was .85.[4]  The BFE was changed from .85 to .96 in 1976, however, some 32 years before Golf Digest published Knuth’s remarks.

The incentive effect for players with indexes of 12.0 and below is also negligible.  Those with integer ATBDs between 0.0 and 12.0 will have identical PE and BE handicaps.[5]  So the only real incentive created by the BFE is for a player to become less than a 12.0 index.   For a great number of players this is a difficult, if not an impossible task. Therefore, the BFE cannot be considered an incentive for most golfers.  It is just a penalty assessed to the high-handicap player in competition against low-handicap players.

In some cases, the BFE is actually a disincentive for improvement.  Table 2 shows the difference between the PE and BE for a course with a Slope Rating of 130.  The BFE penalty does not systematically decrease as a player’s ATBD decreases. For example, as a player improves his ATBD from 35.0 to 30.0 he is at an even greater disadvantage with the scratch player. He now must play at two strokes below his PE handicap rather than one.

Table 2

Bonus for Excellence Penalty (Slope Rating =130)

 

Average of 10 Best Differentials
Perfect Equity Handicap(PE)
Handicap With Bonus for Excellence(BE)
Bonus for Excellence Penalty
BFE Penalty When  Applied to PE
35.0
40
39
1
2
30.0
35
33
2
1
25.0
29
28
1
1
20.0
23
22
1
1
15.0
17
17
0
1
10.0
12
11
1
0
5.0
6
6
0
0
0.0
0
0
0
0

 

The peculiar pattern in BFE penalties is caused by applying the BFE to a player’s ATBD rather than to his handicap.  A systematically decreasing BFE penalty could be constructed by calculating a player’s handicap as the integer value of the product of his perfect equity handicap and the BFE (see Table 2, Column 5).[6]  This would involve changing the method for calculating a player’s index and recalibrating all handicap conversion tables.  This would require a great deal effort with only a negligible impact on the equity of competition and is not recommended.

The total elimination of the BFE, however, is recommended on several grounds.  First, there is no theoretical or empirical justification for its existence.  To argue it provides an incentive to improve is a ruse, and not a very clever one.  Second, it isn’t even an effective reward for the good player.  It is not uncommon for a player with a single digit ATBD to get a 1-stroke BFE reduction, while his high-handicap competitor does not.[7]  Third, no other sport gives a built-in edge to the better player.  (Did Secretariat carry less weight than his rivals?  Do the Charlotte Bobcats spot the Miami Heat 4 points?).  The USGA should be about ensuring equitable competition and not about giving an edge to a group of players it deems more worthy.

The BFE is an anachronism left over from an era when rigorous thought was not always applied in formulating the handicap system.  It is time—actually in 2016 when the USGA Handicap System is revised—for the BFE to go the way of the stymie.   



[1] The USGA Handicap System, 2012-2015, USGA, Far Hills, NJ, p. 77.
[2] Knuth, Dean, ”Handicaps,” Golf Digest, September 2008  as reprinted at www.popeofslope.com.
[3] Men’s USGA Handicap Index Statistics, www.usga.org/articles_resources?Men-s-USGA-Handicap-Indexes.
[4] We say roughly correct because of differences caused by rounding.  A scratch player gains a 1-stroke advantage against a 4-handicap (i.e., only a for 4 stroke difference) who is reduced to a 3-handicap by the BFE.  A 4- handicap and a 10-handicap (i.e., a 6 stroke difference) remain at parity as both are reduced 1-stoke by the BFE. (Note: These calculations assume the players had integer ATBDs and a Slope Rating of 113).
[5] The BFE does shift the breakpoint between handicaps.  For example, without the BFE players with ATBDs between 7.5 and 7.8 are 8-handicaps (Slope Rating =113). When the BFE is applied, these players become 7-handicaps. The beneficiary is the player with a 7.9 ATBD who will now get a stroke from the players with an ATBD between 7.5 and 7.8. In this case, the BFE rewarded the player with less ability.
[6] This would be similar to the procedure for calculating a player’s handicap in four-ball stroke play (i.e., the percentage allowance is applied to a player’s handicap). 
[7] There are cases where a player with an ATBD less that 10.0 would receive a BFE reduction from his perfect equity handicap.  For example, assume a course with a Slope Rating of 80.  Players with ATBDs of 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 6.0, 7.0, and 9.0 do not get a BFE reduction in handicap.  Players with ATBDs of 5.0 and 8.0 do get a BFE reduction of 1- stroke.  Players with ATBDs of 19.0 and 20.0 would not get a BFE reduction.  Better players are less likely to get a reduction, but the sporadic nature of the reduction is another argument for abolishing the BFE.